In 1953, Stanley Miller and Harold Urey performed an experiment at the
University of Chicago to test the hypothesis that the conditions of the early
Earth would have favored the formation of larger, more complex organic
molecules from basic precursors. The experiment, as shown below, consisted of
sealing basic organic chemicals (representing the atmosphere of the primitive
Earth) in a flask, which was exposed to electric sparks (to simulate
lightning) and water vapor.
After one day of exposure, the mixture in the flask had turned pink in color,
and later analysis showed that at least \(10 \%\) of the carbon had been
transformed into simple and complex organic compounds including at least 11
different amino acids and some basic sugars. No nucleic acids were detected in
the mixture.
.Some amino acids, such as cysteine (shown below) and methionine, could not be
formed in this experiment.Which of the following best explains why these
molecules could not be detected?
(A) The chemical reactions necessary to create amino acids such as cysteine
and methionine require more energy than the simulated lightning provided in
the experiment.
(B) The chemical reactions necessary to create amino acids such as cysteine
and methionine require enzymes for catalysis to occur, which were not included
in the experiment.
(C) Sulfur-based compounds were not included in the experiment.
(D) Nitrogen-based compounds were not included in the experiment.