Chapter 2: Problem 88
Which of the following members of cach pair is the stronger Lewis acid? Explain your reasoning. (a) \(\mathrm{BF}_{3}\) or \(\mathrm{NF}_{3}\); (b) \(\mathrm{Al}^{3 *}\) or \(\mathrm{K}^{+}\); (c) \(\mathrm{Mg}^{2+}\) in \(\mathrm{MgF}_{2}\) or \(\mathrm{Mg}^{2+}\) in \(\mathrm{MgCl}_{2}\).
Short Answer
Expert verified
BF3 is a stronger Lewis acid than NF3, Al3+ is stronger than K+, and Mg2+ in MgF2 is stronger than Mg2+ in MgCl2.
Step by step solution
01
Identify Lewis Acid
A Lewis acid is a chemical species that can accept an electron pair. This involves analyzing the ability of a molecule or ion to accept electrons based on its electronic structure and the context such as surrounding ligands and charge.
02
Compare Lewis Acidity of BF3 and NF3
To determine which is a stronger Lewis acid, compare the electronegativity of the central atoms and the vacant p-orbitals. BF3 has a boron atom with an empty p-orbital and is less electronegative than nitrogen in NF3; thus, it is more eager to accept electrons.
03
Compare Lewis Acidity of Al3+ and K+
Al3+ has an empty 3s and 3p orbital and a high positive charge, making it very electron-deficient and a strong Lewis acid. In contrast, K+ is a fully filled, stable ion and doesn't readily seek to accept electrons.
04
Compare Lewis Acidity of Mg2+ in Two Different Compounds
The Lewis acidity of Mg2+ in MgF2 versus MgCl2 can be understood by considering the polarizing power of Mg2+ and the polarizability of the halide ions. F- is less polarizable than Cl-, which means Mg2+ will more strongly attract the electron cloud of F- towards itself, increasing its electron deficiency and thus, Lewis acidity.
Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!
-
Full Textbook Solutions
Get detailed explanations and key concepts
-
Unlimited Al creation
Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...
-
Ads-free access
To over 500 millions flashcards
-
Money-back guarantee
We refund you if you fail your exam.
Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!
Key Concepts
These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.
Lewis Acid Definition
Understanding the concept of Lewis acids is crucial for predicting and explaining chemical reactivity. A Lewis acid is best described as a species with the ability to accept an electron pair. This is often due to the presence of a vacant orbital that can be occupied by a new pair of electrons. In a chemical reaction, Lewis acids typically act as acceptors of electron pairs from Lewis bases, which are electron pair donors. For example, in the case of \textbf{BF}\(_3\) or \textbf{NF}\(_3\), boron trifluoride (\textbf{BF}\(_3\)) is the stronger Lewis acid as it has an empty p-orbital that can accept an electron pair, compared to nitrogen trifluoride (\textbf{NF}\(_3\)) where the nitrogen has no such vacancy.
Lewis acids can be positive ions, neutral molecules, or even an atom within a molecule that bears a partial positive charge due to the surrounding electronegative atoms. This characterization is fundamental in predicting the strength of the Lewis acid, as stronger Lewis acids have a greater tendency to accept electron pairs.
Lewis acids can be positive ions, neutral molecules, or even an atom within a molecule that bears a partial positive charge due to the surrounding electronegative atoms. This characterization is fundamental in predicting the strength of the Lewis acid, as stronger Lewis acids have a greater tendency to accept electron pairs.
Electronegativity
Electronegativity is a chemical property that describes the ability of an atom in a molecule to attract electrons towards itself. It plays a significant role in determining the Lewis acidity of a molecule. Atoms with high electronegativity tend to hold onto their electrons tightly and are less likely to act as Lewis acids. Conversely, atoms with low electronegativity are more capable of serving as Lewis acids because they have a lesser ability to attract electrons and therefore, more readily accept electron pairs from donors.
When comparing \textbf{BF}\(_3\) with \textbf{NF}\(_3\), the central atom, boron, is less electronegative compared to nitrogen. This lower electronegativity translates to boron being more inclined to accept electrons to fill its vacant p-orbital, thereby making \textbf{BF}\(_3\) a stronger Lewis acid.
When comparing \textbf{BF}\(_3\) with \textbf{NF}\(_3\), the central atom, boron, is less electronegative compared to nitrogen. This lower electronegativity translates to boron being more inclined to accept electrons to fill its vacant p-orbital, thereby making \textbf{BF}\(_3\) a stronger Lewis acid.
Orbital Hybridization
Orbital hybridization is crucial in understanding the bonding and structure of molecules, which in turn affects their ability to function as Lewis acids. It refers to the concept of combining atomic orbitals into new hybrid orbitals suitable for the pairing of electrons to form chemical bonds. For Lewis acids, the type of hybrid orbitals present can influence their acidity. Atoms with vacant p-orbitals or low-energy d-orbitals are often strong Lewis acids because these orbitals can easily accommodate electron pairs from Lewis bases.
Take, for instance, boron in \textbf{BF}\(_3\), which has sp2 hybridization and still has an empty p-orbital capable of accepting electrons. This feature makes \textbf{BF}\(_3\) a stronger Lewis acid than \textbf{NF}\(_3\), which lacks such a vacancy.
Take, for instance, boron in \textbf{BF}\(_3\), which has sp2 hybridization and still has an empty p-orbital capable of accepting electrons. This feature makes \textbf{BF}\(_3\) a stronger Lewis acid than \textbf{NF}\(_3\), which lacks such a vacancy.
Electron Deficiency
Electron deficiency occurs when atoms or ions do not have a complete octet of electrons, creating a propensity to accept additional electrons to fulfill their valence shell requirements. This state is directly associated with an entity's Lewis acidic property. The more electron-deficient a species is, the stronger it will be as a Lewis acid. For charged species, the magnitude of the positive charge can indicate the degree of electron deficiency.
As an example, aluminum cation (\textbf{Al}\(^{3+}\)) is more electron-deficient than the potassium cation (\textbf{K}\(^{+}\)), due to its higher positive charge and vacant orbital spaces. Consequently, \textbf{Al}\(^{3+}\) acts as a stronger Lewis acid, seeking electron pairs to attain a stable electronic configuration.
As an example, aluminum cation (\textbf{Al}\(^{3+}\)) is more electron-deficient than the potassium cation (\textbf{K}\(^{+}\)), due to its higher positive charge and vacant orbital spaces. Consequently, \textbf{Al}\(^{3+}\) acts as a stronger Lewis acid, seeking electron pairs to attain a stable electronic configuration.
Polarizability
Polarizability refers to the ability of an electron cloud around an atom or ion to be distorted by an electric field, which in the context of a Lewis acid-base reaction, comes from the charge of a nearby ion or molecule. Larger, more diffuse electron clouds are generally more polarizable. This characteristic impacts the behavior of ions in compounds and influences their Lewis acidity. The more polarizable a ligand is, the less it will shield the central ion from potential electron pair donors, hence increasing the Lewis acid strength of the central ion.
When assessing Mg\(^{2+}\) in \textbf{MgF}\(_2\) versus \textbf{MgCl}\(_2\), we can see that the fluoride ion is less polarizable than the chloride ion. This translates to the magnesium ion in \textbf{MgF}\(_2\) being more electron-deficient and a stronger Lewis acid compared to \textbf{MgCl}\(_2\), where the electron cloud of the chloride ions offers some degree of shielding.
When assessing Mg\(^{2+}\) in \textbf{MgF}\(_2\) versus \textbf{MgCl}\(_2\), we can see that the fluoride ion is less polarizable than the chloride ion. This translates to the magnesium ion in \textbf{MgF}\(_2\) being more electron-deficient and a stronger Lewis acid compared to \textbf{MgCl}\(_2\), where the electron cloud of the chloride ions offers some degree of shielding.