How are the Bohr model and the Rutherford model of the atom similar? How are they different?

Short Answer

Expert verified
Both the Bohr model and the Rutherford model have positively charged nuclei with electrons at a distance. The Bohr model introduces quantized energy levels for electron orbits, unlike the Rutherford model, which doesn't provide such constraints on electron positions.

Step by step solution

01

Identify Similarities

First, identify the similarities between the Bohr model and the Rutherford model. Both models suggest that atoms have a nucleus at the center, and both imply that the nucleus is positively charged. Furthermore, in both models, electrons are thought to exist at some distance from the nucleus.
02

Identify Differences

Next, identify the differences between the two models. The Rutherford model does not provide any explanation for the stability of the electron's orbit around the nucleus, while the Bohr model introduces the concept of quantization of energy levels. Also, Bohr's model restricts electrons to certain orbits or energy levels, whereas Rutherford's does not limit electron positions.
03

Understand the Evolution from Rutherford to Bohr

Understand that the Bohr model was proposed by Niels Bohr in 1913 as an advancement to the atomic model proposed by Ernest Rutherford in 1911. Bohr incorporated quantum theory to address the limitations of Rutherford's model, leading to improved accuracy in predicting atomic behavior.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Atomic Nucleus
The atomic nucleus is a tiny, dense region at the center of an atom, where most of the atom's mass is concentrated. Both the Rutherford and Bohr models recognize the nucleus as comprising protons, which have a positive charge, and neutrons, which have no charge. This central cluster is contrasted with the cloud of negatively charged electrons that surrounds it.

The Rutherford model, proposed in 1911, was revolutionary because it introduced the concept of the nucleus based on the famous gold foil experiment. This experiment provided evidence that atoms consist of a dense nucleus around which electrons revolve. Before this discovery, atoms were thought to be indivisible particles or a 'plum pudding' model where electrons were embedded in a sphere of positive charge.

Bohr's model, presented two years later in 1913, retained the idea of a central nucleus but added new concepts about how electrons exist around this nucleus. The finer details of the atomic nucleus, such as the existence of neutrons, were not yet known at the time these models were proposed, but the presence of a positively charged core was a critical aspect acknowledged by both.
Quantization of Energy Levels
The concept of quantization is a fundamental principle introduced by Bohr, which is absent in Rutherford's model. According to Bohr, electrons can only occupy specific energy levels, called quantum states, and can transition between these levels by absorbing or emitting energy in discrete amounts known as 'quanta.' The quantization of energy levels explains why atoms emit or absorb electromagnetic radiation at specific wavelengths.

In the Bohr model, these quantized energy levels are visualized as distinct orbits around the nucleus, each with a fixed energy value. When an electron jumps from a higher to a lower energy level, it emits a photon of light with an energy equal to the difference between the two levels. This idea was not only revolutionary for understanding atomic structure but also crucial for developing quantum mechanics.

Rutherford's model, on the other hand, did not touch upon the concept of quantized energy states. His model included electrons orbiting the nucleus but could not explain why these electrons do not spiral into the nucleus due to radiating energy, a predicament resolved by Bohr's quantization idea.
Electron Orbits
Electron orbits are the paths that electrons are predicted to follow around the nucleus of an atom. In Rutherford's model, these paths were not well-defined, and electrons were thought to circle the nucleus similar to planets orbiting the sun. Although this offered a visual picture, it failed to provide a stable configuration for the atom, as classical physics would predict that the electrons would lose energy and collapse into the nucleus.

Bohr's improvement on this concept resulted in discrete orbits for electrons, which correspond to certain allowed energy levels. In Bohr's model, an electron orbiting in one of these fixed orbits does not radiate energy, therefore it does not spiral into the nucleus. This was a significant leap in atomic theory as it provided a reason for the atom's stability, which Rutherford's model could not.

By suggesting that the electrons could only 'jump' between these fixed orbits and not exist in between, Bohr introduced the idea of quantum leaps or transitions. This aspect of his model was vital for the later development of quantum mechanics and helped explain a variety of atomic phenomena, including the spectral lines of different elements.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

State the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Describe briefly what the principle implies.

Based on their positions in the periodic table, predict which has the smallest atomic radius: \(\mathrm{Mg}, \mathrm{Sr}, \mathrm{Si}, \mathrm{Cl}, \mathrm{I}\)

Answer the following questions about a Blu-ray laser: (a) The laser on a Blu-ray player has a wavelength of \(405 \mathrm{nm}\). In what region of the electromagnetic spectrum is this radiation? What is its frequency? (b) A Blu-ray laser has a power of 5 milliwatts ( 1 watt \(=1\ \mathrm{J}\ \mathrm{s}^{-1}\) ). How many photons of light are produced by the laser in 1 hour? (c) The ideal resolution of a player using a laser (such as a Blu-ray player), which determines how close together data can be stored on a compact disk, is determined using the following formula: Resolution \(=0.60(\lambda \text { NA), where } \lambda\) is the wavelength of the laser and NA is the numerical aperture. Numerical aperture is a measure of the size of the spot of light on the disk; the larger the NA, the smaller the spot. In a typical Blu-ray system, NA = 0.95. If the 405-nm laser is used in a Blu-ray player, what is the closest that information can be stored on a Blu-ray disk? (d) The data density of a Blu-ray disk using a 405 -nm laser is \(1.5 \times 10^{7}\) bits \(\mathrm{mm}^{-2}\). Disks have an outside diameter of \(120 \mathrm{mm}\) and a hole of \(15-\mathrm{mm}\) diameter. How many data bits can be contained on the disk? If a Blu-ray disk can hold 9,400,000 pages of text, how many data bits are needed for a typed page? (Hint: Determine the area of the disk that is available to hold data. The area inside a circle is given by \(\mathrm{A}=\pi r^{2},\) where the radius \(r\) is one-half of the diameter.)

A photon of light produced by a surgical laser has an energy of \(3.027 \times 10^{-19} \mathrm{J}\). Calculate the frequency and wavelength of the photon. What is the total energy in 1 mole of photons? What is the color of the emitted light?

Which of the following has two unpaired electrons? (a) Mg (b) Si (c) \(\mathrm{S}\) (d) Both Mg and S (e) Both Si and S.

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Chemistry Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.

Sign-up for free