\(({ Dangling-else Problem })\) Determine the output for each of the given sets of code when \(x\) is 9 and \(y\) is 11 and when \(x\) is 11 and \(y\) is \(9 .\) The compiler ignores the indentation in a Java program. Also, the Java compiler always associates an else with the immediately preceding if unless told to do otherwise by the placement of braces \((\\{\\}) .\) On first glance, you may not be sure which if a particular else matches - this situation is referred to as the "dangling-else problem." We've eliminated the indentation from the following code to make the problem more challenging. [Hint: Apply the indentation conventions you've learned.] a) if (x< 10 ) if (y> 10 ) System.out.println( "*****" ); else System.out.println( "#" ); System.out.println( "$$$$$" ); b) if (x< 10 ) { if (y> 10 ) System.out.println( "*****" ); } else { System.out.println( "#" ); System.out.println( "$$$$$" ); }

Short Answer

Expert verified
a) When x=9, y=11: '*****' and '$$$$$'; when x=11, y=9: '$$$$$'. b) When x=9, y=11: '*****'; when x=11, y=9: '#' and '$$$$$'.

Step by step solution

01

- Associate Each else with the Nearest if

In Java, an else statement is associated with the closest previous if that is not already paired with an else, unless braces are used to override this behavior. In the given code, the indentation has been removed, and we must apply this rule to determine the pairs of if-else statements.
02

- Indent Code According to Java Conventions

Properly indent the code to make the control structure clear. Adding the indentation will help us understand which if statement each else belongs to.
03

- Analyze the First Code Segment (a) With x = 9, y = 11

Since x is less than 10 and y is greater than 10, the inner if condition will be true, hence '*****' will be printed followed by '$$$$$' irrespective of the else.
04

- Analyze the First Code Segment (a) With x = 11, y = 9

Because x is not less than 10, the inner if (and its associated else) will be skipped completely, and only '$$$$$' will be printed.
05

- Analyze the Second Code Segment (b) With x = 9, y = 11

As in Step 3, because x is less than 10 and y is greater than 10, the '*****' will be printed, but nothing will be printed from the else block since its associated if condition is not met.
06

- Analyze the Second Code Segment (b) With x = 11, y = 9

Since x is not less than 10, the first if condition is not satisfied and execution moves to the else block, printing '#' followed by '$$$$$'.
07

- Summarize All Outputs

Combine the results from each analysis to determine the final output for each set of code under the given conditions.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Java Control Structures
Java, like many programming languages, implements several control structures to direct the flow of execution within a program. These structures include conditionals (like if, else if, and else), loops (such as for, while, and do-while), and decision-making branches.

Control structures check boolean expressions and determine the execution path based on whether conditions evaluate to true or false. A well-designed Java program will use these structures to perform different actions conditional on runtime data, thus making the program dynamic and flexible.

Correctly using control structures is essential for avoiding logical errors in your code, such as the 'dangling-else problem', which occurs when it's unclear to which if statement an else clause belongs. The best practice is to always use braces ({ }) to explicitly denote which if clause the else is associated with, even when the body contains only one statement. This enhances readability and prevents errors.
Java Conditionals
Conditionals in Java, such as if, else if, and else, are used to perform actions based on true or false boolean expressions. The syntax for an if statement is if (condition) { // actions }, and you can append an else block to execute alternative actions if the condition is false.

When you have multiple if statements and corresponding else clauses, the Java compiler matches each else to the closest preceding if that doesn't already have an else. This simple rule is where the 'dangling-else' issue originates. Without clear structure using indentation or braces, it might not be immediately clear which else belongs to which if, leading to a potential misinterpretation of the intended logic by the programmer.
Code Indentation
Code indentation is not just about aesthetics; it plays a crucial role in understanding the flow and structure of the code, especially in Java. While the Java compiler ignores whitespaces and indentation, developers rely on consistent indentation to quickly ascertain the nesting level of control structures like if-else clauses.

Good indentation practices, such as using a consistent number of spaces or a tab for each indentation level, ensure that the logical structure of the code matches its visual structure. This is key for avoiding the infamous 'dangling-else' problem, where poor or absent indentation can make it incredibly difficult to determine the block of code that an else statement should correspond to.

To further clarify the structure of your code and prevent dangling-else confusion, it's advisable to use braces for blocks under if-else conditions, even when the block contains a single statement. This practice, known as 'defensive programming', helps to make the intent of your code unmistakable not just to the compiler, but also to anyone else who reads your code, including your future self.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

Write four different Java statements that each add 1 to integer variable \(x\).

Fill in the blanks in each of the following statements: a) All programs can be written in terms of three types of control structures: ________, ________ and _______. b) The ________ statement is used to execute one action when a condition is true and another when that condition is false. c) Repeating a set of instructions a specific number of times is called ______ repetition. d) When it's not known in advance how many times a set of statements will be repeated, \(a(n)\) ______ value can be used to terminate the repetition. e) The _______ structure is built into Java; by default, statements execute in the order they appear. f) Instance variables of types char, byte, short, int, long, float and double are all given the value _______ by default. g) Java is a(n) ______ language; it requires all variables to have a type. h) If the increment operator is _______ to a variable, first the variable is incremented by \(1,\) then its new value is used in the expression.

Explain what happens when a Java program attempts to divide one integer by another. What happens to the fractional part of the calculation? How can you avoid that outcome?

(Multiples of 2 with an Infinite Loop) Write an application that keeps displaying in the command window the multiples of the integer 2 -namely, \(2,4,8,16,32,64,\) and so on. Your loop should not terminate (i.e., it should create an infinite loop). What happens when you run this program?

Write an application that reads three nonzero integers and determines and prints whether they could represent the sides of a right triangle.

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Computer Science Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.

Sign-up for free