[Related to Solved Problem 3.3 on page 88\(]\) In The Wealth of Nations, Adam Smith discussed what has come to be known as the "diamond and water paradox": Nothing is more useful than water: but it will purchase scarce anything; scarce anything can be had in exchange for it. A diamond, on the contrary, has scarce any value in use; but a very great quantity of other goods may frequently be had in exchange for it. Graph the market for diamonds and the market for water. Show how it is possible for the price of water to be much lower than the price of diamonds, even though the demand for water is much greater than the demand for diamonds.

Short Answer

Expert verified
The 'diamond and water paradox' is explained through the principles of supply and demand. Even though the demand for water is high and its utility greater than diamonds, the price of water is lower due to its abundant supply. Conversely, diamonds, though offering less utility, command a higher price due to their scarcity.

Step by step solution

01

Graphing the market for water

Create a graph and plot the supply and demand curves for water. The x-axis represents the quantity of water while the y-axis represents the price of water. Draw the demand curve (D) downward sloping from left to right, representing that as price decreases, the quantity demanded increases. Draw the supply curve (S) upwards sloping from left to right, indicating that as price increases, the quantity of water suppliers are willing to provide also increases. The point where the demand and supply curves meet is the equilibrium point, indicating the market price for water.
02

Graphing the market for diamonds

Create a new graph and plot the supply and demand curves for diamonds. Draw the demand curve (D) downward sloping from left to right, indicating that as price decreases, the quantity demanded increases. The supply curve (S) should be steeply upwards sloping from left to right, representing the scarce supply of diamonds, such that a small increase in price results in a significant increase in the quantity of diamonds suppliers are willing to provide. The point where these two curves intersect is the equilibrium point, indicating the market price for diamonds.
03

Comparing Water and Diamonds

The difference in price between diamonds and water, despite the higher demand for water, can be explained by the scarcity of diamonds compared to water. The supply of water is abundant (the supply curve for water is relatively flat), leading to a lower price. Conversely, diamonds are scarce (the supply curve for diamonds is steep), which significantly raises their price. Thus, even though demand for water is greater, its abundant supply leads to a comparatively lower price.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Supply and Demand Curves
Understanding the supply and demand curves is fundamental in economics. These graphical representations illustrate how much of a good or service is desired by consumers at various price points (demand), and how much can be provided by suppliers (supply). The demand curve typically slopes downward, showing that as the price falls, more consumers are willing and able to purchase the good. Conversely, the supply curve generally slopes upward because as the price increases, suppliers are more inclined to produce and sell more.

For instance, water has a high demand at almost any price, because it is a necessity; this would be depicted as a demand curve far to the right on a graph. Diamonds, with less necessity, have lower demand at higher prices. Graphically, the diamond demand curve would start further left compared to water. It's by examining where these curves intersect with their respective supply curves that we find the market equilibrium.
Market Equilibrium
Market equilibrium occurs at the point where the supply curve intersects with the demand curve. At this crossroads, the quantity of the good consumers are willing to buy exactly matches the quantity suppliers are willing to sell at a particular price. This means the market is in balance; there is neither an excess of supply (surplus) nor a deficiency (shortage).

For water, the equilibrium price is likely to be low because the supply is plentiful; the curves meet at a low price point. In the case of diamonds, the natural scarcity shifts the supply curve to the left and its steepness indicates that the quantity available doesn’t increase much even with higher prices, positioning the equilibrium at a much higher price level.
Scarcity and Pricing
Scarcity is a pivotal concept in economics, emphasizing that the limited availability of a resource can lead to increased prices. The more scarce an item is, the steeper its supply curve, indicating that even small increases in quantity supplied require large price increases. Pricing relies on this balance of scarcity and the perceived value of an item by consumers.

In the 'diamond and water paradox', water's abundance leads to a flat supply curve and low prices, whereas diamonds' rarity results in a steep supply curve and high prices. This helps explain why certain goods that are crucial to life—like water—might be cheaper than luxury items like diamonds, which are far less essential but much rarer.
Adam Smith
Adam Smith, often known as the father of modern economics, explored fundamental economic concepts in his seminal work, 'The Wealth of Nations'. Smith discussed the 'diamond and water paradox' to illustrate disparities in value and price. He attributed the paradox to what he termed 'value in use' versus 'value in exchange'. In short, although water has immense 'value in use' due to its necessity for survival, its 'value in exchange' is low because it is so plentiful. Diamonds have little 'value in use' but a high 'value in exchange', due to their allure and rarity. Smith’s explanation emphasizes how markets assign prices not merely based on utility but also on scarcity and consumer preferences.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

In early 2017, an article in the Financial Times about the oil market quoted the chief economist of oil company \(\mathrm{BP}\) as saying, "Pricing pressure is likely to come from the supply side, because of strong growth in US shale oil (crude oil found within shale formations), and the demand side as the rise of renewable energy, including electric vehicles, gradually slows growth in oil consumption." After reading this article, a student argues: "From this information, we would expect that the price of oil will fall, but we don't know whether the equilibrium quantity of oil will increase or decrease." Is the student's analysis correct? Illustrate your answer with a demand and supply graph.

What is the law of demand? Use the substitution effect and the income effect to explain why an increase in the price of a product causes a decrease in the quantity demanded.

Draw a demand and supply graph to show the effect on the equilibrium price in a market in the following situations. a. The demand curve shifts to the right. b. The supply curve shifts to the left.

If a market is in equilibrium, is it necessarily true that all buyers and sellers are satisfied with the market price? Brieflv explain.

A news article about virtual reality headsets observed, "For any hardware platform, it is critical to attract outside developers and build a virtuous cycle in which popular software titles drive hardware sales, which in turn brings in more software developers." The article referred to two types of software: games, such as Final Fantasy, that were already available for video game consoles, and software intended only for use with virtual reality headsets. As both these types of software become available, are they likely to make virtual reality headsets closer or less close substitutes for video game consoles? Briefly explain. Source: Takashi Mochizuki, "Sony's Virtual-Reality Headset Confronts Actual Reality of Modest Sales," Wall Street Journal, February 27 , 2017

See all solutions

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.

Sign-up for free