Chapter 32: Problem 14

Explain and illustrate how a market for human organs could increase the amount of organs available and save lives. Explain and illustrate what would have to occur in order for the lives saved to decline as a result of a legal market for human organs.

Short Answer

Expert verified

Short Answer: A legal market for human organs could potentially increase the supply and availability of organs, allowing more people to access and afford transplants, which would in turn save more lives. However, potential negative factors such as exploitation, decreased organ quality, and organ trafficking could lead to a decline in the number of lives saved if they significantly impact the trust or safety of this organ market. Overall, while a legal market for human organs could save lives, careful regulation and oversight are crucial to prevent negative consequences and ensure the continued viability of such a market.

Step by step solution

1. Increasing Supply of Organs in a Legal Market

In a legal market for human organs, demand can be met by monetary incentives that encourage more people to donate organs. This increased supply of organs helps to address the current shortage faced in organ transplantation. By compensating organ donors or their families, more people may be willing to donate organs, leading to an increase in the availability of organs for transplantation.

2. Illustration: Impact of Increased Availability on Lives Saved

The increase in supply of organs in a legalized organ market can be illustrated by a supply and demand graph. As the supply of organs increases due to monetary incentives (moving the supply curve to the right), the equilibrium price for organs may decrease, allowing more people to access and afford transplants. The increased availability of organs directly leads to more successful transplantations and ultimately, more lives saved.

3. Potential Factors Leading to Decline in Lives Saved

While a legal market for human organs could potentially increase the availability of organs and save lives, there may be factors that could cause a decline in lives saved. Some of these factors include: - Exploitation of vulnerable populations, leading to forced organ donations and decreased quality of life for donors - Decreased quality of organs due to lack of regulations or unethical practices (e.g., poor organ storage conditions) - Organ trafficking and black markets that may negatively impact the healthcare system and overall trust in legal organ markets

4. Illustration: Impact of Factors Causing Decline in Lives Saved

The impact of these factors on the number of lives saved can also be illustrated using a supply and demand graph. If potential negative factors significantly decrease the quality or safety of donated organs, this may lead to a shift in the demand curve to the left, as fewer people are willing to receive transplants from this market, even if organs are more readily available. Consequently, the number of lives saved through successful transplantations may decline, despite the increased availability of organs in the legal market. In summary, a legal market for human organs may increase the supply and availability of organs, directly leading to more lives saved through successful transplantations. However, potential negative factors such as exploitation, decreased organ quality, and organ trafficking could lead to a decline in the number of lives saved if they significantly impact the trust or safety of this organ market.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

Full Textbook Solutions
Get detailed explanations and key concepts
Unlimited Al creation
Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...
Ads-free access
To over 500 millions flashcards
Money-back guarantee
We refund you if you fail your exam.

Start your free trial

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Organ Donation Incentives

The idea of introducing incentives for organ donation stems from the continuous challenge of bridging the gap between the high demand for organs and their scarce supply.

Incentives can vary widely, from financial compensation to prioritized access to transplants for the donors should they need one in the future. Recognizing donors' altruism through benefits such as paid leave, tax credits, or funeral expense assistance could motivate more individuals to participate in organ donation programmes.

Enhancing Donor Pool Through Incentives

These incentives could substantially increase the donor pool by converting the hesitant into willing participants, potentially lowering the number of patients on long waiting lists and ultimately saving more lives. The debate on incentives is complex, involving ethical, legal, and social considerations, with the primary goal being to uphold the dignity and autonomy of donors while addressing the critical need for organs.

Supply and Demand in Organ Transplants

Supply and demand dynamics are crucial in understanding the organ transplant market. Currently, the demand for organs drastically exceeds the supply, leading to long waiting lists and increased mortality for patients awaiting transplants.

A legal market that compensates donors could potentially shift these dynamics, increasing the supply and thereby saving more lives.

Balance between Supply and Demand

By analyzing supply and demand curves, economists can predict how changes in market conditions or policies could affect the availability of organs. If incentives were introduced causing the supply curve to shift to the right, organ prices might decrease, making transplants more accessible to a broader range of individuals. However, the success of this approach relies on careful market regulation to maintain quality and ethical standards in organ procurement.

Ethical Issues in Organ Trade

The organ trade is fraught with ethical questions that challenge the foundation of medical ethics and human rights. Central to the debate is the concern over commodification of the human body and whether it is morally acceptable to put a price on human organs.

Preserving Human Dignity

Some argue that financial incentives could exploit the financially vulnerable, pressuring individuals to make decisions they otherwise would not, especially in low-income settings. This raises the issue of informed consent and the risk of organ trafficking, where organs may be obtained and sold through illegal and unethical means. In addition, there is the potential for a legal market to overshadow the voluntary, altruistic organ donation system, potentially undermining the sense of community and solidarity in healthcare.

Impact of Organ Market Regulation

Regulation of the organ market is vital to prevent exploitation and ensure that organ donation remains safe, ethical, and equitable.

Stringent laws and oversight mechanisms can mitigate potential issues such as organ trafficking, exploitation of vulnerable groups, and medical complications arising from poorly conducted transplant procedures.

A Framework for Safe and Ethical Practices

Effective regulation seeks to create a transparent and fair system that prioritizes patient safety, consent, and the quality of care. It can also ensure that incentives do not lead to unintended consequences, such as reduced altruistic donations or a decrease in organ quality, which could result in a loss of public trust in the system. A robust regulatory framework is the cornerstone for sustaining the balance between supply and demand in the organ market while upholding ethical norms in society.