Chapter 21: Problem 6
State whether each of the following statements is true or false. Explain your answers. a. "All Giffen goods are inferior goods." b. "All inferior goods are Giffen goods."
Short Answer
Expert verified
Statement (a) 'All Giffen goods are inferior goods' is true. Statement (b) 'All inferior goods are Giffen goods' is false.
Step by step solution
01
Understanding Giffen Goods
Recognize that Giffen goods are a specific type of inferior goods. A Giffen good is defined as a product that people consume more of as the price rises, which violates the basic law of demand. This only occurs because the income effect of a price increase for a Giffen good is strong enough to outweigh the substitution effect. Giffen goods are indeed inferior goods, because as the income increases, the demand for these goods decreases.
02
Confirming the truth of statement (a)
Since Giffen goods must be inferior goods in order to qualify as Giffen goods (as the income effect that causes the demand curve to slope upwards would not occur without the good being inferior), the statement 'All Giffen goods are inferior goods' is true.
03
Understanding Inferior Goods
Identify that an inferior good is a good whose demand decreases as consumers' income rises. However, not all inferior goods will see an increase in consumption as their prices rise. They might simply continue to decline in demand or not show any consistent relationship between price and demand like Giffen goods do.
04
Evaluating the truth of statement (b)
As not all inferior goods see increased consumption with a price rise (a must-have characteristic for Giffen goods), the statement 'All inferior goods are Giffen goods' is false.
Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!
-
Full Textbook Solutions
Get detailed explanations and key concepts
-
Unlimited Al creation
Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...
-
Ads-free access
To over 500 millions flashcards
-
Money-back guarantee
We refund you if you fail your exam.
Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!
Key Concepts
These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.
Inferior Goods
Understanding the concept of inferior goods is essential as it lays the foundation for comprehending other economic behaviors like the Giffen goods paradox. Inferior goods are products whose demand decreases when consumers’ income increases. Essentially, as people become wealthier, they tend to buy less of these goods, switching to more expensive substitutes they perceive as better.
For example, if a household's income increases, they might buy less off-brand grocery items and more premium brands instead. Inferior goods have a negative income elasticity of demand, which means the demand moves inversely with income. Nonetheless, not all inferior goods show the unique characteristics of Giffen goods, where demand increases as the price increases; this occurs with only a few goods under specific conditions.
For example, if a household's income increases, they might buy less off-brand grocery items and more premium brands instead. Inferior goods have a negative income elasticity of demand, which means the demand moves inversely with income. Nonetheless, not all inferior goods show the unique characteristics of Giffen goods, where demand increases as the price increases; this occurs with only a few goods under specific conditions.
Income Effect
The income effect explains how changes in consumers’ income levels affect the quantity demanded of a good. When the price of a good rises, and assuming that the income remains unchanged, consumers feel as though they are effectively poorer than they were before. This reduction in real income can lead them to buy less of the good, which is the typical response for most products.
However, in the rare case of Giffen goods, the income effect is so strong that when the price increases, consumers might end up consuming more of the good because they cannot afford the more expensive substitutes, leading to an unusual increase in demand for a product as its price rises.
However, in the rare case of Giffen goods, the income effect is so strong that when the price increases, consumers might end up consuming more of the good because they cannot afford the more expensive substitutes, leading to an unusual increase in demand for a product as its price rises.
Substitution Effect
In contrast to the income effect, the substitution effect occurs when consumers react to a price change by substituting a good with another one that has become relatively cheaper. When prices go up, buyers are likely to seek alternatives, leading to a decrease in demand for the more expensive item. It is the standard market behavior that upholds the basic law of demand—a good's price and its demand are inversely related.
Giffen goods defy this principle because the substitution effect is not strong enough to counteract the income effect. As a result, even as the price of a Giffen good increases, consumers may still maintain or even increase their demand for it due to their inability to switch to alternatives, likely due to a limited budget or the lack of available substitutes.
Giffen goods defy this principle because the substitution effect is not strong enough to counteract the income effect. As a result, even as the price of a Giffen good increases, consumers may still maintain or even increase their demand for it due to their inability to switch to alternatives, likely due to a limited budget or the lack of available substitutes.
Price Elasticity of Demand
The price elasticity of demand measures how the quantity demanded of a good responds to a change in its price. It is an important concept that helps evaluate consumers' sensitivity to price changes. If demand changes greatly with a small price change, the good is said to be elastic. Conversely, a product is inelastic if demand barely changes as the price fluctuates.
Typically, we expect goods to have a negative elasticity; as the price increases, demand falls. Giffen goods, however, are a striking exception, having a positive price elasticity of demand in certain price ranges, meaning that demand increases as the price goes up. This positive elasticity reflects the strong income effect associated with these goods, overpowering the substitution effect and defying conventional price-demand relationships.
Typically, we expect goods to have a negative elasticity; as the price increases, demand falls. Giffen goods, however, are a striking exception, having a positive price elasticity of demand in certain price ranges, meaning that demand increases as the price goes up. This positive elasticity reflects the strong income effect associated with these goods, overpowering the substitution effect and defying conventional price-demand relationships.