Planets with high eccentricity may be unlikely candidates for life because a. the speed varies too much. b. the period varies too much. c. the temperature varies too much. d. the orbit varies too much.

Short Answer

Expert verified
c. the temperature varies too much.

Step by step solution

01

Understanding Eccentricity

Eccentricity is a measure of how much an orbit deviates from being circular. High eccentricity means the orbit is more elongated.
02

Effect on Orbital Speed

With high eccentricity, the speed of a planet changes significantly along its orbit. The planet moves faster when it is closer to the star and slower when it is farther away.
03

Effect on Orbital Period

The period of an orbit is primarily determined by the semi-major axis. High eccentricity does not significantly affect the period of orbit.
04

Effect on Temperature

Due to the elongated nature of the orbit, the distance between the planet and its star varies greatly. This leads to considerable variations in temperature.
05

Evaluating the Options

Considering the impacts explained: high speed variations align with option a; periodic variation due to eccentricity is not significant, so option b is less relevant; significant temperature changes correspond to option c; and varying orbit shape aligns with option d.
06

Choosing the Best Answer

Between the options related to speed and temperature, temperature variance due to the elongated orbit has a more direct impact on the potential for stable life conditions. Hence, option c is the most accurate.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Orbit Variation
Orbit variation refers to the changing shape of a planet's orbit around its star. These changes can affect how close or far a planet gets from its star during different parts of its orbit. When a planet's orbit has high eccentricity, it is more stretched out or elongated. This can lead to periods where the planet is much closer to, and much farther from, its star compared to a more circular orbit. Such fluctuations can dramatically impact the planet's environmental conditions.
High eccentricity in an orbit can affect more than just the shape of the orbit. It influences other aspects such as speed and temperature, which are critical factors for life. Understanding orbit variation is essential to grasping how high eccentricity affects planetary habitability.
To further illustrate:
  • In a circular orbit, the distance between the planet and the star remains constant.
  • In an elongated orbit, the varying distance can cause significant changes in the planet's environment.
Orbital Speed
The speed at which a planet moves around its star is called its orbital speed. This speed can vary greatly, especially in orbits with high eccentricity. In more circular orbits, a planet maintains a relatively consistent speed. However, in highly elongated orbits:
  • The planet travels fastest when it is closest to the star, a point known as perihelion.
  • It moves much slower when it is farthest from the star, a point called aphelion.
This variation in speed can profoundly impact the planet's climate and weather patterns. For example, the rapid movement near the star can cause intense heating, while the slower movement when farther away can lead to extreme cooling. These drastic changes in speed and resultant temperature fluctuations present significant challenges for maintaining stable conditions necessary for life.
The relationship between speed and eccentricity is mathematically explained by Kepler's laws of planetary motion. Essentially, a planet's velocity increases as it gets closer to the star due to the stronger gravitational pull.
Temperature Variation
Temperature variation is a critical factor when considering a planet's habitability. In the context of high orbital eccentricity, the temperature on the planet can vary widely. This happens because the distance between the planet and its star changes dramatically over one orbit cycle.
When the planet is close to its star (perihelion), it absorbs more heat and its temperature rises. Conversely, when the planet is far from the star (aphelion), it receives less heat, and its temperature drops. These extreme fluctuations can make it challenging for any form of life to survive and thrive.
For stable life conditions:
  • The temperature needs to be within a range that allows for liquid water.
  • Extreme temperature variations can cause freezing or boiling of water, making the environment inhospitable.
This is why high eccentricity, leading to major temperature swings, is a key factor in determining a planet's potential for habitability.
Habitability
Habitability refers to the ability of an environment to support life. For a planet to be habitable, several conditions are necessary. One of the most crucial is a stable and moderate range of temperatures, which is heavily influenced by the planet’s orbit.
In orbits with low eccentricity, planets generally experience stable climates conducive to life. However, high eccentricity leads to severe temperature changes, making it difficult for ecosystems to stabilize.
Key factors affecting habitability include:
  • A planet's distance from its star, known as the habitable zone or the “Goldilocks Zone.”
  • Orbital stability and minimal fluctuations in temperature.
  • The availability of liquid water, which can be compromised by extreme temperature variations.
Planets with highly eccentric orbits may experience harmful conditions that are less favorable for sustaining life due to these rapid and extreme changes in environmental conditions. Therefore, understanding and evaluating a planet's orbital characteristics are pivotal in the search for extraterrestrial life.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

Most ancient Greek astronomers were skeptical about the idea that Earth revolved around the Sun because a. of their religious beliefs. b. it feels as though Earth is stationary. c. Earth is so important. d. the heavens were thought to be perfect.

Kepler's first law replaced Copernicus's perfect circles with ellipses, thus shattering the idea that a. Tycho's data were accurate. b. the Sun is at a focus. c. the heavens were perfect, with perfectly round objects and perfectly round orbits. d. Earth goes around the Sun.

When riding in a car, we can sense changes in speed or direction through the forces that the car applies on us. Do we wear seat belts in cars and airplanes to protect us from speed or from acceleration? Explain your answer.

A planet with an eccentricity of 0.5 has a. nearly equal semimajor and semiminor axes. b. a longer semiminor axis than semimajor axis. c. a longer semimajor axis than semiminor axis. d. the Sun at the center of its orbit.

Look up the dates for the next opposition of Mars, Jupiter, or Saturn. One source is the NASA "Sky Events Calendar" at http://eclipse.gsfc.nasa.gov/SKYCAL/SKYCAL.html. Check only the "Planet Events" box in "Section 2: Sky Events"; and in Section \(3,\) generate a calendar or table for the year. As noted in Connections 3.1 , opposition means that the planet will be opposite the Sun in the sky, so it will rise at sunset and set at sunrise. It is also during opposition that the planet is closest to Earth and you can observe retrograde motion. If you are coming up on an opposition, take pictures of the planet over the next few weeks. Can you see its position move in retrograde fashion with respect to the background stars?

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Physics Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.

Sign-up for free