Chapter 20: Problem 3
For all problems, unless otherwise stated, use \(\mathrm{H}_{0}=\) \(70 \mathrm{km} / \mathrm{s} / \mathrm{Mpc}\). Show that, if the universe were infinite in age and extent the cosmological redshift is not sufficient to get us out of Olbers's paradox.
Short Answer
Expert verified
If the universe is infinite in age and extent, cosmological redshift alone cannot explain the darkness of the night sky, failing to resolve Olbers's paradox.
Step by step solution
01
- Understand Olbers's Paradox
Olbers's paradox poses the question of why the night sky is dark if the universe is infinite, static, and filled with stars. Given an infinite number of stars, every line of sight should eventually end on a star, making the sky bright.
02
- Define Cosmological Redshift
The cosmological redshift occurs due to the expansion of the universe. Light from distant galaxies stretches as space expands, which increases its wavelength and shifts it toward the red part of the spectrum.
03
- Infinite Universe Assumption
If we assume the universe is infinite in age and extent, light from stars everywhere should eventually reach us, even if redshifted. The integral over all light emitted by infinite stars should result in significant brightness.
04
- Integrate Light Contribution
Consider the intensity of light from a star that gets redshifted. Even though each individual star’s light decreases in intensity due to the redshift, the cumulative effect of infinite stars contributes a notable amount of light.
05
- Analyze the Impact of Redshift
Redshift alone is not sufficient to significantly attenuate the brightness of light from an infinite number of stars. The brightness will still be significant, and thus the night sky would still not be dark, failing to resolve Olbers's paradox.
Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!
-
Full Textbook Solutions
Get detailed explanations and key concepts
-
Unlimited Al creation
Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...
-
Ads-free access
To over 500 millions flashcards
-
Money-back guarantee
We refund you if you fail your exam.
Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!
Key Concepts
These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.
Cosmological Redshift
The cosmological redshift is a key concept in understanding our universe. It happens due to the expansion of space. As light travels through space, the fabric of space itself stretches. This stretching increases the wavelength of light. Longer wavelengths mean the light shifts towards the red end of the spectrum. Hence, it's termed 'redshift'.
For example, imagine light from a distant galaxy. When this light leaves the galaxy, it starts its journey towards us. Over time, as space expands, this light's wavelength gets stretched. By the time it reaches us, it appears redder than when it started.
This phenomenon helps astronomers figure out how far away objects are. The more redshifted the light, the farther away the object is.
Cosmological redshift not only helps us measure distances but also shows evidence that the universe is expanding.
For example, imagine light from a distant galaxy. When this light leaves the galaxy, it starts its journey towards us. Over time, as space expands, this light's wavelength gets stretched. By the time it reaches us, it appears redder than when it started.
This phenomenon helps astronomers figure out how far away objects are. The more redshifted the light, the farther away the object is.
Cosmological redshift not only helps us measure distances but also shows evidence that the universe is expanding.
Infinite Universe
When we talk about an infinite universe, we mean one that has no bounds and is eternal in age; it has existed forever. In such a universe, every line of sight should eventually end on a star. This situation brings us to a famous problem known as Olbers's Paradox.
According to Olbers's Paradox, if the universe were infinite and filled uniformly with stars, the night sky should be bright. This is because there are an infinite number of stars, and their light should fill up every part of the sky.
But in reality, our night sky is dark, not bright. The paradox challenges the idea of an infinite and static universe. Astronomers have debated this for centuries, and current understanding points towards solutions involving the universe’s expansion and its finite age, among other factors.
According to Olbers's Paradox, if the universe were infinite and filled uniformly with stars, the night sky should be bright. This is because there are an infinite number of stars, and their light should fill up every part of the sky.
But in reality, our night sky is dark, not bright. The paradox challenges the idea of an infinite and static universe. Astronomers have debated this for centuries, and current understanding points towards solutions involving the universe’s expansion and its finite age, among other factors.
Expansion of the Universe
The expansion of the universe is another crucial idea in modern cosmology. Our universe isn't static; it's continuously expanding. This discovery was one of the significant ideas that shifted our understanding of the cosmos.
Edwin Hubble, an astronomer, observed that galaxies are moving away from us, and the farther away they are, the faster they're receding. This observation led to the conclusion that the universe itself is expanding. This expansion affects everything, including the light traveling through space.
As space expands, it stretches the wavelengths of light. This stretching causes the cosmological redshift we talked about earlier. The expansion means that galaxies and stars are constantly moving away from each other, which impacts how we perceive light over long distances.
In terms of Olbers's Paradox, the expansion helps explain why the night sky is dark. As the light from distant stars stretches and redshifts over time, it reaches us with diminished energy, ensuring the sky isn’t as bright as we'd expect in an infinite, static universe.
Edwin Hubble, an astronomer, observed that galaxies are moving away from us, and the farther away they are, the faster they're receding. This observation led to the conclusion that the universe itself is expanding. This expansion affects everything, including the light traveling through space.
As space expands, it stretches the wavelengths of light. This stretching causes the cosmological redshift we talked about earlier. The expansion means that galaxies and stars are constantly moving away from each other, which impacts how we perceive light over long distances.
In terms of Olbers's Paradox, the expansion helps explain why the night sky is dark. As the light from distant stars stretches and redshifts over time, it reaches us with diminished energy, ensuring the sky isn’t as bright as we'd expect in an infinite, static universe.
Intensity of Starlight
The intensity of starlight is essential in resolving questions about the night sky's darkness. Intensity refers to the brightness or energy from a star that reaches us. In an infinite universe, you would think the combined light from all stars should make the night sky very bright.
However, several factors affect this intensity:
However, several factors affect this intensity:
- Cosmological Redshift: Due to the universe's expansion, the light from distant stars gets redshifted, which reduces its energy when it arrives.
- Finite Age of the Universe: The universe is not infinitely old. Light from the farthest stars hasn't had enough time to reach us yet.
- Absorption and Scattering: Interstellar dust and gas can absorb or scatter starlight, diminishing its intensity.