An inventor has built an engine X and claims that its efficiency X is greater than the efficiency of an ideal engine operating between the same two temperatures. Suppose you couple engine X to an ideal refrigerator (Fig. 20-34a) and adjust the cycle of engine X so that the work per cycle it provides equals the work per cycle required by the ideal refrigerator. Treat this combination as a single unit and show that if the inventor’s claim were true(ifεx>ε), the combined unit would act as a perfect refrigerator (Fig. 20-34b), transferring energy as heat from the low-temperature reservoir to the high-temperature reservoir without the need for work.

Short Answer

Expert verified

The combined unit in the figure 20-34bviolates the second law of thermodynamics, so the combined unit can't act as a perfect refrigerator without the need for work.

Step by step solution

01

The given data

The efficiency εxof engine X is εx>ε.

02

Understanding the concept of the second law of thermodynamics

By using equations20-5,20-6and 20-7,(ifεx>ε)we can find if the combined unit would act as a perfect refrigerator, transforming energy as heat from the low-temperature reservoir to the high-temperature reservoir, without the need for work.

Formulae:

The net entropy change per cycle, S=QHTH-QLTL (1)

where, QHand QLare the heats at high and low temperature respectively. Also THand TLare the high and low temperatures respectively.

The second law of thermodynamics equation, S0 (2)

The first law of thermodynamics for a Carnot cycle, W=QH-QL (3)

The efficiency of an ideal Carnot cycle, ε=WQ (4)

03

Calculation to check the claim of the inventor that is (if εx>ε)

The inventor’s claim implies that less heat (typically from burning fuel) is needed to operate his engine than, say, a Carnot engine for the same magnitude of net work done. Then, from the Figure20-34ausing,εx>ε we can see that

Q'H<QH

This implies that the ideal refrigerator unit is delivering more heat to the high-temperature reservoir than engine X draws from it. Therefore, using the concept of energy conservation, we can say that this violates the second law of thermodynamics that is the entropy of the system no more remains positive or zero. So, the combined unit can't act as a perfect refrigerator without the need for work.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

A Carnot air conditioner takes energy from the thermal energy of a room at 70°Fand transfers it as heat to the outdoors, which is at 96°F. For each joule of electric energy required to operate the air conditioner, how many joules are removed from the room?

The motor in a refrigerator has a power of 200 W. If the freezing compartment is at 270 K and the outside air is at 300 K , and assuming the efficiency of a Carnot refrigerator, what is the maximum amount of energy that can be extracted as heat from the freezing compartment in 10.0 min?

Suppose 1.00 molof a monatomic ideal gas is taken from initial pressure p1 and volume V1 through two steps: (1) an isothermal expansion to volume 2.00V1 and (2) a pressure increase to 2.00p1at constant volume. (a) What isQ/p1V1 for step 1 and (b) step 2? What isW/p1V1for (c) step 1 and (d) step 2? For the full process, what are (e)role="math" localid="1661581817879" Eint/p1V1 and (f)S? The gas is returned to its initial state and again taken to the same final state but now through these two steps: (1) an isothermal compression to pressure2.00p1and (2) a volume increase to2.00V1 at constant pressure. What isQ/p1V1 for (g) step 1 and (h) step 2? What isW/p1V1 for (i) step 1 and (j) step 2? For the full process, what are (k)Eint/p1V1and (l)what isS?

A Carnot engine has an efficiency of 22.0 %It operates between constant-temperature reservoirs differing in temperature by 75.0°. (a) What is the temperature of the lower temperature, and (b) What is the temperature of a higher-temperature reservoir?

A 364 gblock is put in contact with a thermal reservoir. The block is initially at a lower temperature than the reservoir. Assume that the consequent transfer of energy as heat from the reservoir to the block is reversible. Figure gives the change in entropy S of the block until thermal equilibrium is reached. The scale of the horizontal axis is set byTa=280KandTb=380K. What is the specific heat of the block?

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Physics Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.

Sign-up for free