Chapter 6: Problem 13
Prove that it is impossible for two reversible adiabatics to intersect. (Hint: Assume that they do intersect and complete the cycle with an isothermal. Show that the performance of this cycle violates the second law.)
Short Answer
Expert verified
Intersecting reversible adiabatics would create a thermodynamic cycle that violates the second law, which is impossible.
Step by step solution
01
- Define Reversible Adiabatic Process
In thermodynamics, a reversible adiabatic process (also known as an isentropic process) is one in which no heat is exchanged with the surroundings, and the entropy of the system remains constant: \[ dS = 0 \]
02
- Assume Intersection of Adiabatic Processes
Assume that two reversible adiabatic processes intersect at some point. Denote this intersection point as point A.
03
- Complete the Cycle with an Isothermal Process
Complete the thermodynamic cycle by connecting point A with two isothermal processes: one at temperature \( T_1 \) and the other at temperature \( T_2 \). Label these processes as B→A and C→A respectively, creating a cycle ABC.
04
- Analyze the Cycle ABC
Analyze the cycle ABC. If A lies on two adiabatics, this means there are two different temperatures \( T_1 \) and \( T_2 \) at which the adiabatics intersect, forming a cycle that seems to perform work from heat flow between two identical points A.
05
- Apply the Second Law of Thermodynamics
According to the second law of thermodynamics, no device can operate in a cycle and produce no net entropy change while producing positive work. Essentially, heat cannot spontaneously flow from a colder body to a hotter body without work being done, violating the second law.
06
- Conclude the Impossibility
Since the assumption of intersection leads to a violation of the second law of thermodynamics, it is concluded that two reversible adiabatics cannot intersect.
Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!
-
Full Textbook Solutions
Get detailed explanations and key concepts
-
Unlimited Al creation
Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...
-
Ads-free access
To over 500 millions flashcards
-
Money-back guarantee
We refund you if you fail your exam.
Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!
Key Concepts
These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.
Second Law of Thermodynamics
The second law of thermodynamics is a fundamental principle governing the direction of heat transfer and the efficiency of thermal systems. It states that in any cyclic process, the entropy of a closed system will either increase or remain the same, but never decrease. This means that energy spontaneously disperses from regions of higher concentration (hotter) to regions of lower concentration (colder).
This principle can be summarized in two main statements:
This principle can be summarized in two main statements:
- Clausius Statement: Heat cannot flow from a colder body to a hotter body without external work being performed on the system.
- Kelvin-Planck Statement: No process is possible whose sole result is the complete conversion of heat into work.
Isentropic Process
An isentropic process is a thermodynamic process in which the entropy of the system remains constant. This typically occurs in an idealized scenario where the process is both adiabatic (no heat exchange with the surroundings) and reversible. The mathematical expression for an isentropic process is given by: \[ dS = 0 \]
When a process is termed isentropic, it implies that the system undergoes changes in state without any increase or decrease in entropy.
In practical terms, isentropic processes are idealizations used to model real-world processes such as those occurring in turbines, nozzles, and compressors, where friction and other irreversibilities are minimized to the extent possible.
For the exercise at hand, assuming the two intersecting processes are isentropic means that their intersection would imply contradictory states where entropy is constant along different intersecting paths, which is inherently impossible.
When a process is termed isentropic, it implies that the system undergoes changes in state without any increase or decrease in entropy.
In practical terms, isentropic processes are idealizations used to model real-world processes such as those occurring in turbines, nozzles, and compressors, where friction and other irreversibilities are minimized to the extent possible.
For the exercise at hand, assuming the two intersecting processes are isentropic means that their intersection would imply contradictory states where entropy is constant along different intersecting paths, which is inherently impossible.
Thermodynamic Cycle
A thermodynamic cycle refers to a series of processes that begin and end at the same thermodynamic state. These cycles are essential in understanding and designing engines and refrigerators. An example of a thermodynamic cycle is the Carnot cycle, which consists of two isothermal and two adiabatic processes.
The significance of thermodynamic cycles lies in their ability to produce work (as in engines) or transfer heat (as in refrigerators) efficiently.
In the exercise, forming a cycle ABC with two adiabatics and one isothermal process means creating a hypothetical machine that violates the second law of thermodynamics. This is because it suggests a perfect conversion between heat and work, without any loss or entropy generation, which defies the fundamental constraints imposed by the second law. Thus, concluding the impossibility of this scenario solidifies the understanding that two reversible adiabatics cannot intersect.
The significance of thermodynamic cycles lies in their ability to produce work (as in engines) or transfer heat (as in refrigerators) efficiently.
In the exercise, forming a cycle ABC with two adiabatics and one isothermal process means creating a hypothetical machine that violates the second law of thermodynamics. This is because it suggests a perfect conversion between heat and work, without any loss or entropy generation, which defies the fundamental constraints imposed by the second law. Thus, concluding the impossibility of this scenario solidifies the understanding that two reversible adiabatics cannot intersect.