Chapter 8: Problem 17
(a) Prove that two isentropic curves do not intersect for systems of two independent variables. (b) Show that isentropic curves do generally intersect for systems with more than two independent variables.
Short Answer
Expert verified
Two isentropic curves do not intersect in systems with two variables, but they can intersect in systems with more than two variables.
Step by step solution
01
Understand Isentropic Curves
Isentropic curves represent states of a system where entropy remains constant, mathematically noted as \(S = \text{constant}\).
02
Isentropic Curves in Two Independent Variables
Consider a system with two independent variables, say pressure (P) and volume (V). Given that entropy (S) is a function of P and V, let's denote this function as \(S(P, V) = \text{constant}\) for one isentropic curve and \(S'(P, V) = \text{constant}\) for another.
03
Intersection of Curves
For two isentropic curves to intersect, there must exist a point \( (P_0, V_0) \) such that both \( S(P_0, V_0) = \text{constant} \) and \( S'(P_0, V_0) = \text{constant} \). If S and S' are indeed different functions, it implies \( S(P, V) eq S'(P, V)\) at all points, preventing intersection.
04
Conclusion for Two Independent Variables
Therefore, two isentropic curves do not intersect for systems characterized by two independent variables, as intersecting would imply the contradiction that two distinct constant entropy values exist at the same state.
05
Isentropic Curves in Systems with More than Two Independent Variables
Consider a system with three independent variables, say pressure (P), volume (V), and temperature (T). Entropy can be expressed as \( S(P, V, T) = \text{constant} \).
06
Intersection in Higher Dimensions
With three independent variables, solving \( S = \text{constant} \) results in a surface in \( (P, V, T) \) space instead of a curve. Several such surfaces can intersect along common lines or points.
07
Conclusion for More than Two Independent Variables
Thus, isentropic curves (or surfaces) in systems with more than two independent variables generally intersect, as multiple entropy surfaces can share common coordinates in the higher-dimensional state space.
Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!
-
Full Textbook Solutions
Get detailed explanations and key concepts
-
Unlimited Al creation
Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...
-
Ads-free access
To over 500 millions flashcards
-
Money-back guarantee
We refund you if you fail your exam.
Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!
Key Concepts
These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.
Independent Variables
In thermodynamics, an independent variable is a quantity that can be varied freely without being affected by other variables in the system. For example, in a system with pressure (P) and volume (V), both P and V are independent variables because you can change one without necessarily changing the other.
When we analyze isentropic curves, these independent variables play a crucial role. An isentropic curve represents a state where entropy remains constant. If we have only two independent variables, such as pressure and volume, the state of the system can be fully described by just these two variables. This means the entropy of the system can be solely expressed as a function of P and V, denoted as:
S = f(P, V)
Due to the fixed relationship between entropy and these two variables, any change in one would adjust the system independently. Therefore, two different isentropic curves cannot exist with the same pair of (P,V) values without causing a contradiction, as each pair would have a unique constant entropy.
When we analyze isentropic curves, these independent variables play a crucial role. An isentropic curve represents a state where entropy remains constant. If we have only two independent variables, such as pressure and volume, the state of the system can be fully described by just these two variables. This means the entropy of the system can be solely expressed as a function of P and V, denoted as:
S = f(P, V)
Due to the fixed relationship between entropy and these two variables, any change in one would adjust the system independently. Therefore, two different isentropic curves cannot exist with the same pair of (P,V) values without causing a contradiction, as each pair would have a unique constant entropy.
Entropy
Entropy is a fundamental concept in thermodynamics that represents the disorder or randomness in a system. It is typically denoted by the symbol S and is a key factor in determining the state and evolution of a thermodynamic system.
For a process to be isentropic, the entropy remains unchanged. This is significant because it implies a reversible and adiabatic process. In simpler terms, during an isentropic process, there is no heat exchange with the surroundings, and the process can be reversed without loss of energy or increase in entropy.
Isentropic curves serve to show the states where entropy is constant. If a system is described by only two variables, the system's state can be represented on a two-dimensional plot (e.g., a P-V diagram), and two different isentropic curves would never intersect. This is because each state combination of P and V corresponds to a unique entropy value, setting clear and separate paths for different entropy levels.
In higher dimensions (systems with more than two independent variables), entropy remains an essential concept. But now, entropy surfaces can exist where multiple combinations of independent variables can represent different states of the system. These surfaces can intersect, allowing the entropy to be constant along intersecting lines or points despite changes in other variables.
For a process to be isentropic, the entropy remains unchanged. This is significant because it implies a reversible and adiabatic process. In simpler terms, during an isentropic process, there is no heat exchange with the surroundings, and the process can be reversed without loss of energy or increase in entropy.
Isentropic curves serve to show the states where entropy is constant. If a system is described by only two variables, the system's state can be represented on a two-dimensional plot (e.g., a P-V diagram), and two different isentropic curves would never intersect. This is because each state combination of P and V corresponds to a unique entropy value, setting clear and separate paths for different entropy levels.
In higher dimensions (systems with more than two independent variables), entropy remains an essential concept. But now, entropy surfaces can exist where multiple combinations of independent variables can represent different states of the system. These surfaces can intersect, allowing the entropy to be constant along intersecting lines or points despite changes in other variables.
Thermodynamic Systems
Thermodynamic systems are the physical systems we study in thermodynamics. They can be defined as a quantity of matter or a region in space chosen for analysis. Everything outside this system is considered the surroundings, and the boundary separates the system from its surroundings.
Thermodynamic systems can be categorized mainly into three types:
Understanding these systems and their classifications are crucial when dealing with entropy and isentropic curves. For instance, in a closed system with two independent variables like P and V, we can plot isentropic curves that indicate no heat exchange occurs. However, in systems with three or more independent variables, isentropic surfaces replace the simpler curves. These surfaces can intersect, indicating that the balance of entropy could be maintained even when multiple variables change, as long as these changes occur in a specific, balanced manner.
Thermodynamic systems can be categorized mainly into three types:
- Open Systems: Systems that exchange both matter and energy with their surroundings
- Closed Systems: Systems that exchange only energy but not matter with their surroundings
- Isolated Systems: Systems that do not exchange matter or energy with their surroundings
Understanding these systems and their classifications are crucial when dealing with entropy and isentropic curves. For instance, in a closed system with two independent variables like P and V, we can plot isentropic curves that indicate no heat exchange occurs. However, in systems with three or more independent variables, isentropic surfaces replace the simpler curves. These surfaces can intersect, indicating that the balance of entropy could be maintained even when multiple variables change, as long as these changes occur in a specific, balanced manner.