Chapter 3: Problem 26
Two cranes are lifting identical steel beams at the same time. One crane is putting out twice as much power as the other. Assuming friction is negligible, what can you conclude is happening to explain this difference?
Short Answer
Expert verified
Answer: The possible reasons for the difference in power output between the two cranes include the time taken to lift the beams, the displacement or height to which the beams are lifted, or a combination of both factors. The second crane might be lifting the beam faster, to a greater height, or both.
Step by step solution
01
Define power and work
Power is the rate at which work is done, and work is the product of force and displacement. Mathematically, power (P) can be represented as P = W/t, where W is the work done and t is the time taken. When lifting objects, work done (W) is equal to the force (F) applied by each crane, multiplied by the vertical displacement (d) of the object.
02
Apply the power and work formulas to the two cranes
Let P1 and P2 be the power output of the first and second cranes, respectively. From the given information, we know that P2 = 2 * P1. Let W1 and W2 be the work done by the first and second cranes, respectively. Since both cranes are lifting identical steel beams, the force required to lift the beams is the same. Therefore, we can write the work equations for both cranes as:
W1 = F * d1
W2 = F * d2
03
Identify potential reasons for the power differences
Given that the force to lift the beams is the same but the power output from the second crane is twice that of the first crane, there must be differences in the time taken (t1 and t2) and the displacement (d1 and d2) covered to lift the beams. We can now rewrite the power equations for both cranes as:
P1 = W1 / t1 = F * d1 / t1
P2 = W2 / t2 = F * d2 / t2
Since P2 = 2 * P1, we can write: F * d2 / t2 = 2 * (F * d1 / t1)
04
Analyze the possible reasons for the power differences
There are three possible reasons that could explain the difference in power:
1. The second crane is lifting the beam twice as fast as the first crane. If this is the case, then t2 = 1/2 * t1.
2. The second crane is lifting the beam to twice the height as the first crane. In this case, d2 = 2 * d1.
3. A combination of both the factors mentioned above, i.e., the second crane is lifting the beam faster and to a greater height than the first crane.
05
Conclusion
The difference in power output between the two cranes can be attributed to the time taken, displacement, or both. The second crane might be lifting the beam faster, to a greater height, or a combination of these factors, while both cranes exert the same force on the identical steel beams, assuming negligible friction.
Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!
-
Full Textbook Solutions
Get detailed explanations and key concepts
-
Unlimited Al creation
Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...
-
Ads-free access
To over 500 millions flashcards
-
Money-back guarantee
We refund you if you fail your exam.
Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!
Key Concepts
These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.
Work-Energy Theorem
The work-energy theorem is a fundamental principle in physics that relates the work done on an object to the change in its kinetic energy. According to this theorem, the work done by the net force acting on an object equals the change in its kinetic energy. Mathematically, it can be expressed as
\[ W_{\text{net}} = \Delta KE \]
where \( W_{\text{net}} \) is the net work done on the object and \( \Delta KE \) represents the change in kinetic energy. This theorem is particularly useful when analyzing the motion of objects when forces are applied to them. In a situation like the crane lifting a steel beam, the energy input through work is being translated into gravitational potential energy as the beam rises. Understanding this concept can help students evaluate such scenarios and recognize relationships between force, energy, and motion.
\[ W_{\text{net}} = \Delta KE \]
where \( W_{\text{net}} \) is the net work done on the object and \( \Delta KE \) represents the change in kinetic energy. This theorem is particularly useful when analyzing the motion of objects when forces are applied to them. In a situation like the crane lifting a steel beam, the energy input through work is being translated into gravitational potential energy as the beam rises. Understanding this concept can help students evaluate such scenarios and recognize relationships between force, energy, and motion.
Power Output
Power output is a measure of how quickly work is done or energy is transferred. It is a vital concept in aspects of physics that involve energy transformation and doing work over time. Power is defined as the work done per unit of time, and the standard unit of power in the international system of units is the watt (W).
\[ P = \frac{W}{t} \]
where \( P \) is power, \( W \) is the work done, and \( t \) is the time taken to do the work. For the cranes scenario, the difference in power output suggests that the faster crane is doing the same amount of work in less time or doing more work in the same amount of time.
\[ P = \frac{W}{t} \]
where \( P \) is power, \( W \) is the work done, and \( t \) is the time taken to do the work. For the cranes scenario, the difference in power output suggests that the faster crane is doing the same amount of work in less time or doing more work in the same amount of time.
Force and Displacement
In physics, the concepts of force and displacement are interconnected through the idea of mechanical work. When a force causes an object to move, work is done on that object. Displacement refers to the distance and direction an object has moved from its initial position, and it is often denoted by the symbol \( d \). The relationship between force \( F \), displacement \( d \), and work \( W \) is given by
\[ W = F \cdot d \cdot \cos(\theta) \]
where \( \theta \) is the angle between the force vector and displacement vector. In the context of the cranes, the direction of the force is vertically upward, and the displacement is also vertical, meaning the \( \cos(\theta) \) term is equal to 1, simplifying the formula to \( W = F \cdot d \). The difference in power output of the cranes can thus also be related to these fundamental concepts of force and displacement.
\[ W = F \cdot d \cdot \cos(\theta) \]
where \( \theta \) is the angle between the force vector and displacement vector. In the context of the cranes, the direction of the force is vertically upward, and the displacement is also vertical, meaning the \( \cos(\theta) \) term is equal to 1, simplifying the formula to \( W = F \cdot d \). The difference in power output of the cranes can thus also be related to these fundamental concepts of force and displacement.
Mechanical Work
Mechanical work transpires when a force is applied to an object and moves it. It's a form of energy transfer and a key concept for any system where forces cause motion. The equation for work is
\[ W = F \cdot d \cos(\theta) \]
The direction and amount of force, along with the object’s displacement, determine how much work is done. If the force and displacement are in the same direction, the cos(\theta) is 1, simplifying the equation to \( W = F \cdot d \). For the crane situation in the exercise, assuming both cranes apply the same force, the crane doing more work in the same time (or the same work in less time) shows a higher power output. It's essential that students understand the critical relation between force, movement, and energy transfer to thoroughly grasp mechanical work concepts.
\[ W = F \cdot d \cos(\theta) \]
The direction and amount of force, along with the object’s displacement, determine how much work is done. If the force and displacement are in the same direction, the cos(\theta) is 1, simplifying the equation to \( W = F \cdot d \). For the crane situation in the exercise, assuming both cranes apply the same force, the crane doing more work in the same time (or the same work in less time) shows a higher power output. It's essential that students understand the critical relation between force, movement, and energy transfer to thoroughly grasp mechanical work concepts.