Chapter 2: Q46P (page 87)
Imagine a bead of mass m that slides frictionlessly around a circular wire ring of circumference L. (This is just like a free particle, except that find the stationary states (with appropriate normalization) and the corresponding allowed energies. Note that there are two independent solutions for each energy En-corresponding to clockwise and counter-clockwise circulation; call them and How do you account for this degeneracy, in view of the theorem in Problem 2.45 (why does the theorem fail, in this case)?
Short Answer
The conclusion is that this theorem fails because:
(1) does not go to zero at infinity
(2) x is restricted to a finite range
(3) we are unable to determine the constant K