A projectile is a distance r from the center of a heavenly body and is heading directly away. Classically, if the sum of its kinetic and potential energies is positive, it will escape the gravitational pull of the body, but if negative, it cannot escape. Now imagine that the projectile is a pulse of light energy E. Since light has no internal energy ,E is also the kinetic energy of the light pulse. Suppose that the gravitational potential energy of the light pulse is given by Newton’s classical formula U=-(GMm/r), where M is the mass of the heavenly body and m is an “effective mass” of the light pulse. Assume that this effective mass is given by m=E/c2.

Show that the critical radius for which light could not escape the gravitational pull of a heavenly body is within a factor of 2 of the Schwarzschild radius given in the chapter. (This kind of “semiclassical” approach to general relativity is sometimes useful but always vague. To be reliable, predictions must be based from beginning to end on the logical, but unfortunately complex, fundamental equations of general relativity.)

Short Answer

Expert verified

The critical radius for which the light could not escape the gravitational pull of a heavenly body is within a factor of 2 of the Schwarzschild radius, is proved.

Step by step solution

01

Identification of given data

The given data can be listed below as:

  • The distance of the particle from the heavenly body is r.
  • The energy of the projectile is E.
  • The mass of the heavenly body is M.
  • The effective mass of the light pulse is m.
02

Significance of the critical radius

The critical radius is mainly described as the lowest radius which an atom form. It is also described as the minimum size of a particle.

03

Determination of the critical radius

As the total energy of the particle is zero, then the equation of the total energy is expressed as:

KE + PE = 0

Here, KE is the kinetic and PE is the potential energy.

Substitute E for KE and-GMmrfor PE in the above equation.

E-GMmr=0

Here, E is the energy of the particle, G is the gravitational constant, M is the mass of the heavenly body, m is the effective mass of the light pulse and r is the distance of the particle from the heavenly body.

Substitute Ec2for in the above equation.

E-GMErc2=0E1-GMrc2=0

The next equation can be expressed as:

1-GMrc2=01=GMrc2r=GMc2

The equation of the Schawzschild radius is expressed as:

rs=2GMc2

Here, rsis the Schawzschild radius.

Here, in the case of the Schawzschild radius, it can be identified that the critical radius is lesser than the factor of 2 than the Schawzschild radius.

Light can only escape the gravitational pull if the addition of the kinetic and the potential energy is greater than zero but, in this case, the addition is equal to zero.

Thus, the critical radius for which the light could not escape the gravitational pull of a heavenly body is within a factor of 2 of the Schwarzschild radius, is proved.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

Question: Equation (2-38) show that four-momentum of a particle obeys a Lorentz transformation. If we sum momentum and energy over all particles in a system, we see that the total momentum and energy also constitute a four-vector. It follows that (Etotal/c)2-Ptotal2 is the same quantity in any frame of reference. Depending on what is known, this can be a quicker route to solving problems than writing out momentum and energy conservation equations. In the laboratory frame, a particle of mass m and energy Ei collide with another particle of mass initially stationary, forming a single object of mass . (a) Determine the frame of reference where the after-collision situation is as simple as possible, then determine the invariant in that frame. (b) Calculate the invariant before the collision in the laboratory frame in terms of M and Ei . (You will need to use Ei2/c2-p2=m2c2 for the initially moving particle to eliminate its momentum.) Obtain an expression for M in terms of m and Ei . (c) Write out momentum and energy conservation in the laboratory frame, using uf for the speed of the initially moving particle and for the speed of the final combined particle. Show that they give the same result for M in terms of m and Ei. (Note: The identity γu2u2=γu2c2-c2 will be very handy.)

How much work must be done to accelerate an electron

(a) from 0.3cto 0.6cand

(b) from 0.6cto 0.9c?

The light from galaxy NGC 221 consists of a recognizable spectrum of wavelengths. However, all are shifted towards the shorter-wavelength end of the spectrum. In particular, the calcium “line” ordinarily observed at 396.85nmis observed at 396.58nm. Is this galaxy moving toward or away from Earth? At what speed?

Question: The Lorentz transformation equations have x and t and x' and t'. Why no v and v' ?

Question: A rocket maintains a constant thrust F, giving it an acceleration of g

(i.e.,9.8m/s2).

(a) If classical physics were valid, how long would it take for the rocket’s speed to reach 0.99c??

(b) Using the result of exercise 117(c), how long would it really take to reach 0.99c??

u=11+(Ft/mc)2FTt

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Physics Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.

Sign-up for free