Imagine that our Sun was somehow replaced by a \(1-\mathrm{M}_{\odot}\) white dwarf star, and that our Earth continued in an orbit of semimajor axis \(1 \mathrm{AU}\) around this star. Discuss what effects this would have on our planet. What would the white dwarf look like as seen from Earth? Could you look at it safely with the unaided eye? Would the Earth's surface temperature remain the same as it is now?

Short Answer

Expert verified
Replacing the Sun with a 1-Msol white dwarf star would lead to a substantial decrease in light and heat received by Earth. The white dwarf would appear smaller but could be potentially harmful to look at directly due to its high surface brightness. This lack of solar radiation will also decrease the Earth's surface temperature, potentially causing a global ice age.

Step by step solution

01

Understanding the nature of a white dwarf star

Firstly, it is important to realize that a white dwarf star is smaller and cooler than the Sun. Though their mass may be similar to that of the Sun, their size is comparable to that of the Earth. So, the entire radiation emitted by the white dwarf is spread over a smaller surface area and thus its radiated power (luminosity) is smaller.
02

Discussing the effects of a white dwarf as the centerpiece of our solar system

Since the luminosity of the white dwarf is less than the sun, our world will be much darker and cooler, potentially causing a global ice age. As a result, most life forms as we know them would likely cease to exist. The white dwarf will also appear much smaller than the sun.
03

Safety of viewing the white dwarf with the naked eye

Despite being cooler and less luminous, the emitted light from a white dwarf is more concentrated due to its small size. This means the white dwarf could have a greater surface brightness than the Sun, depending on its temperature. So, looking at it directly could potentially be harmful for the eyes.
04

Analyzing the change in Earth's surface temperature

Owing to the decreased luminosity and consequent decreased radiation that Earth would receive, it is likely that the Earth's surface temperature would decrease significantly. This could potentially plunge the earth into a permanent winter state.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

White Dwarf Characteristics
White dwarfs are fascinating celestial bodies, remnants of stars like our own Sun after they have expended most of their nuclear fuel. Despite having a mass similar to the Sun's, usually around \(1-\text{M}_{\odot}\), they are incredibly small, roughly the size of Earth. This vast difference in volume compared to normal stars like the Sun leads to extreme density, where their atoms are packed together tightly.

Unlike the raging infernos of their previous stages, white dwarfs emit energy that is a remnant of their past thermonuclear processes. This leads to a luminosity far less than that of our Sun and a cooler temperature. It is this lower luminosity and innate coolness that significantly influences their impact on surrounding celestial bodies.
Effects of White Dwarf on Earth
Should our Sun be replaced by a white dwarf, the consequences for Earth would be dire. The decreased luminosity would mean less heat and light reaching our planet, creating a much darker and cooler environment. This could initiate a global ice age, eradicating many life forms accustomed to Earth's current climate.

The white dwarf's gravity would still maintain Earth's orbital path due to their similar masses. However, without adequate warmth and light, Earth's biosphere would undergo drastic changes, potentially collapsing ecosystems and hindering the process of photosynthesis, which is essential for life as we know it.
Luminosity of White Dwarf
A white dwarf's luminosity is significantly lower than that of the Sun. Luminosity, the total amount of energy a star emits per second, is a crucial factor affecting the climate of planets in its orbit. For a white dwarf, the compressed nature of its physical structure leads to reduced luminosity, despite its surface temperature being relatively high.

This reduced emission of energy and light means that, were a white dwarf to replace the Sun, the Earth would receive considerably less radiation, insufficient to maintain our current atmospheric and surface temperatures. For example, the white dwarf's output might not sustain the present-day hydrological cycle, leading to alterations in weather patterns and potentially the loss of surface water through freezing.
Viewing White Dwarf Safely
Contrary to what you might expect, the safety of viewing a white dwarf with the unaided eye is not guaranteed. Despite their lower overall luminosity, white dwarfs can exhibit a high surface brightness due to the concentrated emission of light over a smaller area.

Therefore, looking directly at a white dwarf could pose risks similar to staring at the Sun and should be done with caution. Proper solar filtration or indirect viewing techniques, such as pinhole projectors or eclipse glasses, should be utilized to observe these dense remnants of stars safely.
Earth's Surface Temperature Change
The surface temperature of Earth is inextricably linked to the amount of solar radiation it receives. If a white dwarf were to take the Sun's place, the substantial drop in luminosity would lead to a significant decrease in Earth's surface temperature.

The cooler, less intense radiation would be insufficient to sustain our current temperate climate. This could plunge our world into a prolonged state of winter, drastically transforming the environment. Areas that are currently habitable might become inhospitable due to the extreme cold, affecting not only human life but the entire flora and fauna on the planet.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

The major final product of silicon fusion is \({ }^{56} \mathrm{Fe}\), an isotope of iron with 26 protons and 30 neutrons. This is also the most common isotope of iron found on Earth. Discuss what this tells you about the origin of the solar system.

The Ring Nebula is a planetary nebula in the constellation Lyra. It has an angular size of \(1.4\) arcmin \(\times 1.0\) arcmin and is expanding at the rate of about \(20 \mathrm{~km} / \mathrm{s}\). Approximately how long ago did the central star shed its outer layers? Assume that the nebula is 2,700 ly from Earth.

Although they represent a fleeting stage at the end of a star's life, planetary nebulae are found all across the sky. Some of the brightest are listed in the accompanying table. Note that the distances to most of these nebulae are quite uncertain. Observe as many of these planetary nebulae as you can on a clear, moonless night using the largest telescope at your disposal. Note and compare the various shapes of the different nebulae. In how many cases can you see the central star? The central star in the Eskimo Nebula is supposed to be the "nose" of an Eskimo wearing a parka. Can you see this pattern?

Search the World Wide Web for information about SN 1994I, a supernova that occurred in the galaxy M.51 (NGC 5194). Why was this supernova unusual? Was it bright enough to have been seen by amateur astronomers?

. Use a telescope to observe the remarkable triple star 40 Eridani, whose coordinates are R.A. \(=4^{\mathrm{h}} 15.3^{\mathrm{m}}\) and Decl. \(=-7^{\circ} 39^{\prime}\). The primary, a 4.4-magnitude yellowish star like the Sun, has a 9.6-magnitude white dwarf companion, the most easily seen white dwarf in the sky. On a clear, dark night with a moderately large telescope, you should also see that the white dwarf has an 11 th-magnitude companion, which completes this most interesting trio.

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Physics Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.

Sign-up for free