In mechanics, one often uses the model of a perfectly rigid body to model and determine the motion of physical objects (see, for example, Chapter 10 on rotation). Explain how this model contradicts Einstein's special theory of relativity.

Short Answer

Expert verified
#Question# Explain the contradiction between the model of a perfectly rigid body in classical mechanics and Einstein's special theory of relativity. #Answer# The contradiction between the model of a perfectly rigid body and Einstein's special theory of relativity arises from the fact that according to special relativity, objects experience length contraction when travelling at very high speeds near the speed of light. This means that the distance between two points within an object will change depending on the object's relative speed to the observer. However, a perfectly rigid body assumes that the distance between any two points remains constant regardless of external forces and conditions. This idea is inconsistent with the concept of length contraction observed in special relativity.

Step by step solution

01

Define a perfectly rigid body

A perfectly rigid body is a simplified model of a physical object used in classical mechanics. In this model, the distance between any two points within the body remains constant, no matter the applied forces or torques. This means that a rigid body cannot be deformed, stretched, or compressed.
02

Briefly explain Einstein's special theory of relativity

Einstein's special theory of relativity, developed in 1905, revolves around the ideas that the laws of physics are the same for all observers in inertial frames (frames moving at a constant velocity), and that the speed of light in a vacuum is constant for all observers, regardless of their relative velocities. The theory introduces concepts of space-time, time dilation, length contraction, and mass-energy equivalence.
03

Identify the contradiction

The contradiction between the model of a perfectly rigid body and Einstein's special theory of relativity arises from the fact that in special relativity, objects contract in the direction of their motion (length contraction) when traveling at very high speeds (close to the speed of light). This means that the distance between two points within an object will change depending on the object's relative speed to the observer. As a perfectly rigid body assumes that the distance between any two points remains constant regardless of external forces, it contradicts the concept of length contraction observed in special relativity.
04

Elaborate on the contradiction with a thought experiment

Consider a hypothetical rigid rod with a length of L in its rest frame (frame where the rod is not moving). Now, imagine moving the rod at a high speed (close to the speed of light) with respect to another observer in another frame. According to the special theory of relativity, the observer will see the rod's length contract due to the high relative speed. However, for the rod to remain perfectly rigid, the distance between any two points on the rod must remain constant, which contradicts the length contraction observed in special relativity. Therefore, the model of a perfectly rigid body is inconsistent with Einstein's special theory of relativity.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Einstein's Special Theory of Relativity
Albert Einstein's groundbreaking paper on the special theory of relativity, introduced in 1905, forever changed our understanding of space, time, and motion. At its core, this theory put forth two postulates which seem deceptively simple: the laws of physics are the same for all non-accelerating observers, and the speed of light in a vacuum is the same for all observers, no matter their relative speed.

What unfolds from these two postulates is a framework that blends space and time into a single continuum known as space-time. Events that occur are not absolute but are relative to the motion of observers. This leads to mind-bending predictions, such as time dilation and length contraction, which have been confirmed through numerous experiments. For instance, time dilation implies that time passes at a slower rate for objects moving at high speeds, while length contraction implies that objects appear shorter in the direction of motion when moving at high speeds, as perceived by a stationary observer.
Perfectly Rigid Body
In contrast to Relativity, Classical Mechanics often involves the concept of a perfectly rigid body. This model is a theoretical construct where the distances between any parts of the object do not change. In essence, it's an object that doesn't compress, stretch, or deform, no matter the amount of stress or force exerted on it.

This idealized model simplifies calculations and is a useful approximation for many engineering problems where speeds are not relativistic, which means they are much slower than the speed of light. For all intents and purposes, under ordinary conditions, an iron beam or a wooden plank could be thought of as 'almost' perfectly rigid. However, this notion becomes problematic when speeds approach the realm of relativistic effects.
Classical Mechanics
When we look at Classical Mechanics, which encompasses the physics developed by Sir Isaac Newton, it is based on principles and laws that describe the motion of objects at everyday speeds and sizes. The cornerstone of classical mechanics, Newton's laws, accurately predicts how objects move under the influence of forces. For many practical applications in our daily life, from constructing buildings to playing sports, classical mechanics serves us extremely well.

However, it becomes evident that Classical Mechanics does not consider the effects of traveling at high velocities, where it's integral to account for relativistic phenomena. It's at these high velocities, nearing the speed of light, that classical presumptions, such as time being a constant and space being absolute, begin to crumble, revealing a realm where Einstein's theory takes precedence.
Length Contraction
One of the intriguing outcomes of Einstein's theory is the concept of length contraction. This occurs because, according to relativity, as an object moves faster, space itself seems to contract along the direction of motion from the perspective of a stationary observer. The formula for length contraction is given by \( L = L_0 \sqrt{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}} \) where \( L \) is the contracted length, \( L_0 \) is the rest length (the length of the object at rest), \( v \) is the velocity of the object, and \( c \) is the speed of light.
Time Dilation
Closely related to length contraction is time dilation, a phenomenon where time passes at a slower rate for an object in motion relative to a stationary observer. This effect becomes appreciable only at speeds comparable to the speed of light. Mathematically, the time dilation effect is described by \( t = \frac{t_0}{\sqrt{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}} \) where \( t \) is the time interval measured by the stationary observer, \( t_0 \) is the proper time interval (the time measured by a clock moving with the object), \( v \) is the relative velocity, and \( c \) is the speed of light.

This phenomenon is not just a theoretical prediction; it has practical implications and has been experimentally verified, for example, in the operation of the Global Positioning System (GPS), where engineers must account for time dilation effects to ensure accuracy.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

Suppose NASA discovers a planet just like Earth orbiting a star just like the Sun. This planet is 35 light-years away from our Solar System. NASA quickly plans to send astronauts to this planet, but with the condition that the astronauts would not age more than 25 years during this journey. a) At what speed must the spaceship travel, in Earth's reference frame, so that the astronauts age 25 years during this journey? b) According to the astronauts, what will be the distance of their trip?

Using relativistic expressions, compare the momentum of two electrons, one moving at \(2.00 \cdot 10^{8} \mathrm{~m} / \mathrm{s}\) and the other moving at \(2.00 \cdot 10^{3} \mathrm{~m} / \mathrm{s}\). What is the percentage difference between classical momentum values and these values?

Consider a positively charged particle moving at constant speed parallel to a current-carrying wire, in the direction of the current. As you know (after studying Chapters 27 and 28), the particle is attracted to the wire by the magnetic force due to the current. Now suppose another observer moves along with the particle, so according to him the particle is at rest. Of course, a particle at rest feels no magnetic force. Does that observer see the particle attracted to the wire or not? How can that be? (Either answer seems to lead to a contradiction: If the particle is attracted, it must be by an electric force because there is no magnetic force, but there is no electric field from a neutral wire; if the particle is not attracted, you see that the particle is, in fact, moving toward the wire.)

A proton with a momentum of \(3.0 \mathrm{GeV} / \mathrm{c}\) is moving with what velocity relative to the observer? a) \(0.31 c\) c) \(0.91 c\) e) \(3.2 c\) b) \(0.33 c\) d) \(0.95 c\)

Consider a particle moving with a speed less than \(0.5 c\). If the speed of the particle is doubled, by what factor will the momentum increase? a) less than 2 b) equal to 2 c) greater than 2

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Physics Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.

Sign-up for free